Search court cases and case law in the UK

SEARCH THE SITE

Stephen Lewendon v. International Paper (UK) Limited [2011] CSOH 116

Description

The pursuer sought damages for injuries sustained by him in the course of his employment at the defender's paper mill. In January 2009, the pursuer's right arm was drawn into machinery, which latterly required the surgical amputation of this limb to the elbow, preventing him from being able to continue in his employment with the defender. The defender relied upon contributory negligence in defence. Moreover, the defender submitted that the calculation of wage loss would depend on a range of variables, perhaps involving the Ogden Tables, therefore meaning that special cause, to merit the case not being decided by a jury, was shown.

Having heard submissions on this point, the court concluded that it was likely there would be real dispute between the parties on the pursuer's true wage loss, which would mean two or more calculations using the Ogden Tables before any jury; the issues at stake were likely to be complex and detailed.
The court accepted that civil juries as a matter of course will often be perfectly capable of resolving wage loss disputes with the aid of the Ogden Tables in normal cases. On this occasion however, the case was of a sufficiently difficult nature and involved a multiplicity of calculations, such that the jury's task would be too difficult. The court therefore concluded that the likely complexities of the case gave rise to special cause for withholding it from jury trial under section 9(b) of the Court of Session Act 1988.

Specifications

Share

CaseCheck
www.casecheck.co.uk
TwitterFacebookGoogle+YouTube